Skip to main content

Support & FAQs

The Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit 

Frequently Asked Questions Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit 

What is the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit?

The Sustainable Cities Challenge - Detroit is calling for innovators to enter with solutions that will meet the below Challenge Statement:

Demonstrate solutions that reduce fossil fuel use and cut costs of freight operations ​in Eastern​ Market.

Solutions should address one or more of the following:

  1. Reduce idling time
  2. Reduce partial loads and empty miles
  3. Reduce reliance on fossil fuel for cold chain logistics and freight management
  4. Reduce implementation costs and barriers to adopting clean freight technologies

We will support innovators to develop their solutions by providing:

  • Up to ten $50,000 implementation grants in the semi-finalist stage
  • Up to five  $130,000 implementation grants in the finalist stage
  • $1.5 million final implementation funding, to be shared among up to 3 winners 
  • The opportunity to engage directly with city leaders 
  • Connections to businesses in Eastern Market to understand their operations
  • Access to city stakeholders including problem-holders, end users and beneficiaries  
  • Access to a network of like-minded innovators. 
When does the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit run?

Entries to this Challenge are open from​ UTC 29 May 2024 and close by 16:00 UTC on 12 September 2024.

Entries will be assessed against the judging criteria and the successful semi-finalists will be announced in November 2024.  

After the semi-finalist stage comes to an end, successful finalists will be announced some time in May 2025.

Winners will be announced in early 2026. 

How can I find out more about the Challenge?

Below is a list of resources or other ways you can find out more about the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit:

How is the Challenge funded?

The Sustainable Cities Challenge is funded by the Toyota Mobility Foundation.

What grant funding is available and how can I use it?

The implementation grant funding is available by stage of the Challenge as indicated below:

  • Up to ten implementation $50,000 grants in the semi-finalist stage
  • Up to five $130,000 implementation grants in the finalist stage
  • $1.5 million final implementation funding, to be shared among up to 3 winners
  • The opportunity to engage directly with city leaders
  • Access to various stakeholders, e.g. mobility providers.
  • Access to a network of like-minded innovators 

All funding must be used by teams to develop, test, demonstrate, and implement their solutions.

The final implementation funding should be used to implement the solution. As part of their final submission, each finalist must put forward ideas for what this implementation would look like for their solution, with input and discussion with the Toyota Mobility Foundation. 

Who is running the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit?

The Sustainable Cities Challenge is led and funded by the Toyota Mobility Foundation, in partnership with Challenge Works and  World Resources Institute

Who is the Toyota Mobility Foundation?

The Toyota Mobility Foundation (TMF) was established in August 2014 by the Toyota Motor Corporation (Toyota) to support the development of a more mobile society in which everyone can move freely.  

The Foundation underscores Toyota’s ongoing commitment to continuous improvement and respect for people. It utilizes Toyota’s expertise and technologies to support strong mobility systems while eliminating disparities in mobility. TMF works in partnership with universities, governments, non-profits, research institutions and other organizations, creating programs that are aligned with the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to address mobility issues around the world.  

In the past, TMF has led a range of Challenges, including the global Mobility Unlimited Challenge, CATCH in Malaysia and InoveMob Challenge in Brazil. You can find out more about TMF and how it is governed at toyotamobilityfoundation.org  

Who are Challenge Works?

Challenge Works is a global leader in the design and delivery of open innovation challenges that mobilise diverse, innovative thinkers to solve pressing problems and unlock change. Founded by Nesta, the UK’s innovation foundation for social good, Challenge Works is a social enterprise that has delivered over 90 challenges to date and distributed more than £156 million to winning innovators.

 https://challengeworks.org/  

Who are World Resources Institute?

World Resources Institute (WRI) is a global research organization that works with governments, businesses, multilateral institutions and civil society groups to develop practical solutions that improve people’s lives and ensure nature can thrive. They organize our work around seven global challenges: Food, Forests, Water, Energy, Climate, the Ocean and Cities. They analyze these issues through the lenses of our four Centers of Excellence: Business, Economics, Finance and Equity. Visit them at wri.org

Who are the Office of Mobility Innovation (OMI)?

Detroit, Michigan, USA is known as the Motor City and has a heavy manufacturing and commercial freight industry. The city has reinvented itself after deindustrialization, and there are plenty of opportunities to continue this evolution and improve sustainable mobility. In areas such as the Eastern Market, a thriving food and cultural hub, the pollution and congestion from freight present an area of possible innovation.  

Entering the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit - section of FAQ

Who can enter the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit?

Only entries that meet the eligibility criteria can enter the Challenge.  

The Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit eligibility criteria:

  • The solution must be designed specifically for and implemented within the city of Detroit.
  • Entrants can be single organizations or consortia.  
  • Teams that enter as a consortia must nominate one organization as the lead entrant. The lead entrant will enter into contracts and receive funding from Toyota Mobility Foundation.  
  • Entrants must already be established as a legally incorporated organization to be selected for the next phase of the Challenge. 
  • The Challenge is open to innovators worldwide, but entries must be in English.
  • Successful entrants must be willing and able to travel to the city for which they are entering as there will be expectations for on-the-ground presence during the next stage of the Challenge.  
  • Entrants must own or be licensed to use relevant intellectual property included in their entries. If your entry proposes a new idea, we expect that you will own all the resulting intellectual property, which may be registered on a local basis if you become a successful participant in the Challenge. The Challenge would not be able to give you specific legal advice on the protection or exploitation of intellectual property.
How can I enter the Challenge?

You need to fill out the online entry form before the entry deadline at 16:00 UTC on 12 September 2024.  

The online entry form is hosted on Submittable, a social impact platform used to collect submissions. You can access it here.  

Remember to read the ​​Entrant Handbook and Terms and Conditions before you submit your entry.  

In what language should my entry be in, and what language will the Challenge be run in?

The Sustainable Cities Challenge is being run in English. Only entries submitted in English will be eligible for the Challenge.

Can I enter as a consortium or with a co-entrant?

Yes, you can enter as a consortium or with a co-entrant. If you do enter as a consortium, you must nominate one organization as the lead entrant.  

The lead entrant will enter into contracts and receive funding from Toyota Mobility Foundation. 

What is the selection process?

Eligible entries will be evaluated against the Judging Criteria. Those that best meet the criteria will be invited to participate in the semi-finalist stage.

Can I submit more than one entry?

Yes, you can submit more than one entry to the Challenge. 

Is entry to the Challenge confidential?

Entries to the Challenge will be confidential; however, they will be shared with those involved in running and assessing entries, including our delivery partners and the judging panel. Details of entries will be considered as part of our ongoing evaluation activities and may form evidence for future policy developments. No evidence published, following our evaluation, will be attributable to individual entries or entrants.  

If you are successful in being selected to participate in the Challenge, one of the conditions of accepting support (both financial and non-financial) will include publicity of your initiative. 

Please review the full Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy for full details.  

Do entrants retain their intellectual property rights for their idea? 

Entrants ​must ​own ​or ​have ​written ​permission ​to ​use, ​the ​intellectual ​property ​relevant to ​their ​entry. ​All entrants ​need ​to ​demonstrate ​a ​willingness ​to ​share ​information ​about their ​solution ​for ​the ​purposes ​of ​the ​Challenge. As ​part ​of ​the ​Challenge, the Toyota Mobility Foundation, the City of Detroit, Challenge Works, and other ​​partners ​intend to ​carry ​out ​publicity ​activities and ​publish ​reports ​about ​the ​insights ​gained through ​the ​Challenge. ​These ​activities ​will ​not ​divulge ​confidential ​intellectual ​property.  

If I have more questions, what should I do?

You can email us at [email protected].

You can also sign up for a webinar or book a one-to-one session. For a full list of the support available, see the Entrant Support section on the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit page.  

The Three City Challenges under the Sustainable Cities Challenge - section of FAQ

What are the three City Challenges?

This FAQ page relates to the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit.  

However, there are three different city Challenges under the Sustainable Cities Challenge. Each of them is focused on their specific city and has a completely different mobility-related challenge. 

They are:  

  1. The Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit  – Transforming Freight  
  • The Detroit Challenge is calling on  innovators to demonstrate solutions that reduce fossil fuel use and cut costs of freight operations in Eastern Market. 
  • Entries to this Challenge are open from 29 May 2024 and close by 16:00 UTC on Monday 12 September 2024.
  • You can visit the  Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit page here

     

  1. The Sustainable Cities Challenge Venice  – Embracing Sustainable Mobility  
  • The Venice Challenge is calling on innovators to create solutions that change behavior, increasing the use and adoption of existing low and zero-carbon transport modes in the city of Venice. 
  • Entries to this Challenge are open from Tuesday 11 June 2024 and close by 12:00 UTC on Monday 30 September 2024. 
  • You can visit the Venice Challenge page here.  

 

  1. The Sustainable Cities Challenge Varanasi –  Innovating Crowd Flow  
  • The Varanasi Challenge is calling on innovators to create data-driven solutions that make crowded areas of Varanasi’s old city (Kashi) safer and more accessible.
  • Entries to this Challenge are open from Thursday 27 June 2024  and close by 13:00 UTC on Thursday 5 September 2024 
  • You can visit the Varanasi Challenge page here.
Can I enter all three of the City Challenges?

Yes, you can make an entry to all three City Challenges. However, you will likely not be selected for more than one City Challenge unless you demonstrate the capacity to work on two Challenges at the same time.

Other - section of FAQ

I am interested in being a Challenge Supporter; what should I do?

We’d love to hear from you! Please send us an email us at [email protected]

What data is available to me as I put together my entry?

You can find all the information available to entrants in the entrant handbook. 

Other specific data is not available at this time. However, a package of relevant data will be available to innovators by the time the semi-finalist stage begins.

We also encourage you to schedule a one-to-one call or sign up for an informational webinar, to ask us questions.  

What is the main goal of the challenge? Are there any additional pain points from the customer beyond those mentioned in the provided materials?

Freight operators in the Eastern Market are not primarily concerned with pollutants, especially in terms of health. Their main concern is the expansion of the market. One key pain point is that margins are very thin, so innovation can be problematic if it adds costs and further impacts profitability.

What kind of solution is expected from the teams?

During the semi-final period, you will not need to implement your solution. Instead, you should focus on refining and adapting your solution before demonstrating and piloting it.

Is it possible to connect with other companies who are considering entering for the purposes of finding partners or collaborators?

Due to data protection laws, we cannot share contact details. However, if you email us indicating that you are happy for us to share your contact details with anyone else interested in partnering, we can connect you with other interested parties. 

Are there any preferences for the types of solutions, or are we looking for a specific type of solution?

No, we care about impact against the judging criteria and also consider the Eastern Market operators and their needs. 

Would the challenge team facilitate partnerships and collaborations?

Yes, the 10 semi-finalists will have the opportunity to connect and collaborate during the next phase as finalists. Additionally, an Innovator Academy will be hosted. 

Is there any support offered to navigate the city of Detroit’s regulations?

Detroit offers support for regulatory concerns and has facilities to assist with these issues. However, support will be handled on a case-by-case basis depending on the specific concerns and needs. Please schedule a 1:1 call or email us with your questions for more detailed assistance. 

On the online entry form (on the Submittable platform) can I save my entry as I work?

Yes, you can save your entry as you work on it and submit it when you are ready. However, we recommend that you always keep a back-up of your entry offline to ensure you do not lose your entry in case of any technical issues.  

On the online entry form (on the Submittable platform) can I transfer ownership of my entry to someone else?

Yes, you can change ownership of the entry form on Submittable. You can find guidance on how to do that here: https://submittable.help/en/articles/9655256-transfer-submission-ownership-for-submitters 

Do I need to have my whole team or all the capacity before I enter?

No, you do not.

How is vehicle and fleet flow managed at Eastern Market?

Logistics management is in place, but the flow of vehicles into specific spaces is not centrally controlled. There is no granular, top-down mechanism managing this process. Solutions addressing this level of logistics management would require significant buy-in from market operators.

When and how are the markets structured?

Multiple markets operate simultaneously at the same location. For example, a restaurant vendor can make a single stop to get what they need.

The public market is held on Saturdays, Sundays, and Tuesdays. There is a diary and scheduling system in place for this. The space and vendors for the public markets differ from those used at other times, as they require more space and accommodate additional vendors.

Is there a defined procedure for how things work or how they normally happen?

Logistics operations staff at the market are familiar with the procedures. For example, Shed 7 has refrigeration facilities, and they monitor market throughput. 

Is there an appetite to create more centralized management?

The Eastern Market partnership aims to evolve and improve without disrupting current operations.

Does the solution need to address all of Eastern Market, or can it be more focused?

Starting small and scalable is preferred.

Are diesel trucks predominantly used, or is there infrastructure for electric vehicles?

Most trucks are diesel Class 8 vehicles that distribute goods throughout the city. There is limited infrastructure for electric vehicles, though there are fast chargers available, depending on the scale. No Class 8 electric vehicles have been used yet. The cold temperatures in Detroit pose a challenge for EVs, but they may be suitable for short runs to restaurants. The city is exploring both hydrogen and electric vehicles as alternatives.

Can companies from the around the world can participate with or without a partner from Detroit, USA?

Yes, companies from the around the world can participate without needing a partner from Detroit or the U.S. During the semi-finalist stage, you can explore what’s needed to establish your business in the U.S. Detroit is open to innovative ideas from around the world. 

Has there been any coordination with the community of freight operators or operators of logistics fleets in the area?

Currently, there is no centralized management for the markets; they operate independently. Freight operators coordinate directly with shed operators and the Eastern Market Partnership to determine where they can distribute their goods. However, the Eastern Market Partnership doesn't have a fully coordinated agreement with all vendors, meaning each entity largely manages its own operations. 

Can we at least start making revenue during this process, working with companies in the Eastern market? Or are we limited to not making any revenue off it?

As long as you're achieving the contractual obligations for the sustainable cities challenge. And if you happen to be, generating revenue at the same time. 

How does the truck system work? Are they owned and operated by the vendor companies themselves? Or is there a separate agency operating the trucks?

They are owned and operated by the vendors or contracted leasing through a couple of larger Lessing organizations. There is no central management or ground traffic control. 

In terms of partners, we will engage with will be partnered up with. Would they be willing to collect data for a second phase?

We're helping by facilitating connections between Detroit and various stakeholders, but not directly brokering partnerships. Currently, we're gathering publicly available and vendor data to identify key data points needed for future collaboration. The exact data required will depend on the partnerships formed and their specific needs. 

Enter the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit

The call to innovators is now open. Enter the Challenge today.

The deadline to submit your entry is 16:00 UTC on 12 September 2024. 

Enter the Sustainable Cities Challenge Detroit
people cars
About the Challenge
Support & FAQs